Undocumented Immigration By Congressional District
The American Immigration Law Foundation (AILF) has an interesting article that lists the approximate number of illegal immigrants in each U.S. Congressional District. The relevance of this information is to give an insight into the reasons for the immigration law votes of U.S. Representatives. For instance, in my own congressional district, the 32nd District in Texas, the approximate number of undocumented aliens is 120,000 -- slightly over 18% of the total population. Yet my Representative, Congressman Pete Sessions, is strongly against comprehensive immigration reform. Here are quotes from the article:
Continue Reading...Introduction:
Over the past year, Congress has debated major changes to immigration law as a response to undocumented immigration. While this debate has relied heavily upon estimates of undocumented immigration at the national level, less attention has been paid to the number of undocumented immigrants in local areas--and almost no analyses have considered the size and scope of undocumented immigration in each of the 435 congressional districts. Yet the size of the undocumented population in each congressional district is an important consideration in gauging whether or not a representative's stance on a particular immigration policy or initiative has a basis in the actual, local impact of undocumented immigration.
An earlier IPC analysis showed that the number of undocumented immigrants was surprisingly low in the districts of key representatives leading the effort to restrict immigration. For example, there are relatively few undocumented immigrants in the districts of either Rep. Tom Tancredo (R-6th/CO), chair of the Congressional Immigration Reform Caucus, or Rep. F. James Sensenbrenner (R-5th/WI), chair of the House Judiciary Committee. Both were champions of H.R. 4437, the Border Protection, Anti-Terrorism, and Illegal Immigration Control Act--an enforcement-only immigration bill passed by the House of Representatives on December 16, 2005.1
However, the extent of undocumented immigration in congressional districts is important for reasons beyond the interpretation of a representative's voting record. Undocumented immigrants are counted by the census, the population estimates of which are used to apportion congressional districts, to re-draw the districts of state representatives and senators, and to delineate districts for a wide variety of municipal services (schools, police, fire protection, etc.). In addition, undocumented immigrants have a significant impact on local economies if they are present in sizable numbers. On the one hand, they contribute by paying taxes, purchasing consumer items, and--increasingly--becoming homebuyers. On the other hand, they utilize health care and social services that can strain local and state budgets. Moreover, many undocumented immigrants live in households that include native-born children, meaning that the welfare of millions of U.S. citizens depends in large part on the welfare of their undocumented parents.